Bachelor for an evening, so what do I do? Rent a movie, of course! Last night I watched the Director’s Cut of Watchmen, and I’m still trying to decide what I thought of it.
I read lots of comics growing up, but never read Watchmen. I was a strictly Marvel Comics guy, so Watchmen, which was a DC Comic, was for some reason not cool. Anyway, last May, on Free Comic Book Day, I picked up a free copy of the first issue of Watchmen, and thought it was pretty interesting. It was the first comic I had read in over 20 years. I wanted to know what happened next, and since the movie had just come out, I figured I’d find out someday.
One fun thing about comics is that they all occur in an alternate world not so different from our own. Watchmen’s premise takes us to a somewhat believable yet fantastic mirror-world, in the sense that if you accept just one crazy unbelievable thing, the world very well could have turned out the way it’s portrayed in the comic. In Watchmen, it’s 1985 in New York City, and the U.S., which won the Vietnam War, is still being led by Richard Nixon in his 5th term (I suppose the 22nd Amendment was repealed somewhere in there). This alternate reality came about in large part because of (here’s the required “suspension of disbelief”) a superhero, Dr Manhattan, who was a nuclear scientist who got caught in an accident that gave him near-godlike superpowers. It’s because Dr Manhattan was used as a weapon by the US government in Vietnam that Nixon is reelected, etc, etc.
The plot has three main levels: Globally, impending nuclear war due to the tensions between the US and the USSR, a situation made more worse by the continued existence of Dr Manhattan. Locally in NYC, the fear of vigilantes on the street fighting crime resulted in the passage of a law banning “masked adventurers,” meaning that Batman-like crime-fighters essentially all go into retirement, and there’s lots of public fear and resentment toward them. And on the personal level, we watch the post-crime fighting lives and relationships of former “masked adventurers” — what do they do after they’ve been forced to retire from crime fighting?
It all comes together to make a great backdrop for a story. One of the things I liked best is the way the movie pays homage to the vintage comic stories. The opening credits of the movie are really masterful at setting the stage, and the music choice is perfect (in fact, I thought the music choices and score were really exceptionally good throughout — read the first comment on the Amazon page, which echoes what I thought).
Unfortunately, I think the movie fell a little short of its promise, and for me, it was the backdrop and its execution, more than the actual story, that kept me engaged. The interpersonal relationships, I thought, were pretty poorly developed (“Why are they friends?” “What does she see in him?”). The action scenes were fun, but at 2 hours and 43 minutes (24 minutes of which was extra director’s cut footage), it was far too long.
But still, have to say it was worth the $4 rental.