
There’s been a lot of talk — maybe too much talk — about Apple’s new iPhone. While I have no doubt it’ll be great device, and I’m sure I’ll want to get one, I probably won’t, as I’ve decided that my current Treo 650 has nearly everything that the iPhone has — with a couple of exceptions that would be nice extras, but not things I’d use most of the time anyway.
What do I love about my Treo?
- I have it already. I’ve had it for a year and a half, as has everybody else. You know what they say about a bird in the hand. The iPhone bird won’t be sighted in the wild for another 6 months. Which brings us to…
- Developers have it already. And they have for about 10 years. The basic Palm platform has spawned thousands of add-on apps. Most of those aren’t worth the bits they’re made out of, but some are quite good. There’s a small industry of Palm development companies out there, and some apps (like Documents To Go) go quite a long way toward expanding the functionality of the device. It’s not clear what the 3rd party development situation will be for the iPhone.
- It syncs perfectly with my computer. Apple’s iSync doesn’t do that — but Mark/Space’s Missing Sync does. And this isn’t a phone issue, it’s an iSync issue. If Apple can’t do complete syncing (like multiple addreses, calendar categories, etc) correctly with their own built-in app to my phone, I have my doubts about the future, which will feature all syncing through iTunes (why?). I really hope I’m proven wrong about this. Also, I have 3rd party apps to sync other digital media from computer to phone (MS Office documents and text files) — the iPhone may not even read these, much less sync them.
- It works on my carrier. Not just my personal carrier (T-Mobile), but my unlocked Treo works on nearly any carrier, around the world. And there are versions for almost all non-GSM carriers, too, some of which tout data speeds faster than the iPhone. And I like my carrier, at least for its pricing scheme for data, which is half of what I would likely pay on Cingular with the iPhone (though that hasn’t been announced yet). And the iPhone won’t come unlocked, and I’m betting Cingular won’t unlock it, either.
- It has nearly every application that the iPhone has. Nearly every one, and for all intents and purposes, the ones it doesn’t have are gravy. I can make calls, organize contacts, take photos, browse the web, and send e-mail from multiple accounts with the built-in software on the Treo. With additional software, I could play MP3s and movies, too, and there’s a free Google Maps client built specifically for the Treo.
- It has a QWERTY keyboard, Bluetooth, and EDGE data. Yes, the physical, button-laden keyboard is a plus and a minus, but I like having it. This touchscreen thing will have to be seen to be believed — and nobody but the Pogues and Mossbergs of the world have seen it yet. Bluetooth and “high speed” data are necessities for any phone these days, and my phone has them.
So, there are lots of things that the iPhone has that might be interesting down the road (WiFi, 4-8GB of storage, big touchscreen, nice-looking interface), but since the announcement, I’ve realized that my phone does most of this, and basically all I want it to do. I just wish it were thinner. But, considering my current phone, which I would have thought would be completely outdated nearly two years after it was announced, the iPhone really doesn’t serve up any additional functionality that I need. That’s why I still love my Treo. At least until June.